Open for comment · closes December 1
Stop the National Park Service from opening 147,000 acres of Big Cypress to off-road vehicles without a public map
National Park Service · Big Cypress National Preserve, FL
- What
- This rule would open roughly 147,000 acres in the Big Cypress Addition to ORV designation authority, but the controlling map that defines those areas is not available in the public docket.
- Where
- Big Cypress National Preserve, FL
- How much
- In the Addition, which the rule would open to ORV designation: approximately 147,000 acres. Total acreage of the National Preserve: over 729,000 acres. Original Preserve acreage at establishment: 582,000 acres.
- By when
- Comments to National Park Service by December 1, 2026.Date from Federal Register ↗, read October 29, 2026.
What to ask forAll 10 points →
The agency should publish a plain-language summary of the BAP's impact findings for the Addition directly in the rulemaking record, or explain precisely which BAP sections and findings the rule relies on and why those findings are adequate for the regulatory action being taken.
Where these four lines come from
- WhatOur plain-English read of the Federal Register 2026-20251 ↗. Check it against the agency’s own words under Case.
- WhereThe places and states the notice names, as PLAN read them.
- approximately 147,000 acres“In 1988, Congress expanded the boundary to include within the National Preserve an additional approximately 147,000 acres, an area referred to as the Addition.” Purpose and Significance of Big Cypress National Preserve Open the document ↗
- over 729,000 acres“Protecting over 729,000 acres of this vast swamp, the National Preserve contains a mixture of tropical and temperate plant communities” Purpose and Significance of Big Cypress National Preserve Open the document ↗
- 582,000 acres“The original boundary of the preserve surrounded 582,000 acres. This area is referred to as the Original Preserve.” Purpose and Significance of Big Cypress National Preserve Open the document ↗
- By whenDecember 1, 2026, from Federal Register, the notice's DATES field (federalregister.gov API) ↗: “Comments must be received by 11:59 pm EDT on December 1, 2026.”. Read October 29, 2026.
- Read from PLAN’s record November 16, 2026.
Two ways to be heard on this, and both count. Comment for the legal record, then call the members who answer to you.
Comment nowWhat to say
Make these points, in your own words
The proposed rule opens approximately 147,000 acres in the Addition to potential ORV use, but the Federal Register notice provides no environmental analysis of its own for that expansion.Read the point +
The agency says this rule merely implements the ROD and BAP, but the notice contains zero site-specific impact data, no summary of impacts to soils, hydrology, or listed species in the Addition, and no stand-alone NEPA analysis attached to the rulemaking itself. Readers are told only that the BAP EIS exists elsewhere online. Under NEPA, a proposed rule with direct environmental consequences must carry or incorporate by reference a sufficient analytical record in the rulemaking docket. The agency should publish a plain-language summary of the BAP's impact findings for the Addition directly in the rulemaking record, or explain precisely which BAP sections and findings the rule relies on and why those findings are adequate for the regulatory action being taken.
The rule characterizes itself as a 'deregulatory action' under Executive Order 14192 that 'expands consumption options' and increases 'recreation and access,' but the same document acknowledges that ORV use has been prohibited in the 147,000-acre Addition since at least 1988 because the 1975 map did not cover it.Read the point +
Treating the removal of a long-standing prohibition as deregulation that requires no cost-benefit showing contradicts the agency's own account of the legal status quo. The agency should explain why a rule that opens roughly 147,000 additional acres to motorized vehicles qualifies as a purely deregulatory action with no countervailing costs, and it should disclose whether that characterization caused any required economic analyses to be omitted or truncated.
The Tribal consultation section concedes that the Miccosukee and Seminole Tribes shared a specific view about the human-land relationship and that the selected alternative was chosen 'in part because it is responsible to the concerns expressed' by the Tribes, yet the notice provides no description of what those concerns were, what routes or areas the Tribes objected to, or how the selected alternative addresses those concerns.Read the point +
At the same time, the agency determined that formal Tribal consultation was 'not required' for this rulemaking. Given that there are 15 active traditional villages, active ceremonial grounds, and active burial grounds in the Preserve, the agency should either conduct formal Tribal consultation on this proposed rule and publish the results, or explain in detail why the BAP consultation record fully covers the regulatory action now proposed.
The notice states that the special regulations refer to a 1975 map and that 'this map is outdated and does not depict the current boundary of the National Preserve,' yet the replacement map (numbered 26-001, dated May 1, 2026) is described only as 'available for public inspection at the office of the Superintendent.'Read the point +
There is no link, no image, and no description of its contents in the Federal Register notice or the online docket as described. Commenters cannot meaningfully evaluate what areas are being opened or closed without seeing the controlling map. The agency should make map 26-001 directly available in the public docket on regulations.gov before the comment period closes, so that any member of the public can examine it without traveling to Ochopee, Florida.
The notice states that ORV use has been managed since 2000 through the Superintendent's Compendium, which designates specific routes and closes all other locations.Read the point +
It then says this rule will allow the Superintendent to designate routes in the Addition 'consistent with the selected alternative in the ROD, which does not allow for dispersed ORV use.' But the rule text itself does not codify any prohibition on dispersed use in the Addition; it simply opens areas to motorized vehicles subject to the Superintendent's discretion. Nothing in the amended regulatory text prevents a future Superintendent from compendium-opening broad areas rather than discrete routes. The agency should amend the regulatory text to expressly prohibit dispersed ORV use in the Addition and limit authorization to designated routes, matching the stated intent of the ROD.
The notice asserts that the rule 'would not have an annual effect on the economy of $100 million or more' and lists no significant adverse effects on competition or employment, yet the Regulatory Flexibility Act analysis is contained only in a separate document available at an external website and is not summarized in the Federal Register notice itself.Read the point +
Small entities, including outfitters, guides, and hunting camp operators who depend on access to the Addition, cannot assess their regulatory exposure without locating and reading that separate report. The agency should publish at minimum a summary of the IRFA findings in the Federal Register notice, including the number of small entities affected and the nature and estimated magnitude of the impacts, as the RFA requires.
Congress directed the Secretary to 'carefully regulate' ORV use to protect 'natural, wildlife, and wilderness values,' and the legislative history is cited as evidence of that intent.Read the point +
The notice states the National Preserve contains the Florida panther, a federally listed species. Yet the proposed rule contains no discussion of Section 7 consultation with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service specifically for this rulemaking, and no mention of any Biological Assessment or Biological Opinion covering the regulatory action of opening 147,000 acres in the Addition to ORV designation authority. The agency should disclose whether a Section 7 consultation was completed for this proposed rule as distinct from the BAP, and if not, explain why the BAP consultation is legally adequate to cover the rulemaking.
The notice describes a 60-day public comment window (October 2 to December 1, 2026) for a proposed rule that opens roughly 147,000 acres to ORV designation authority, involves listed species including the Florida panther, implicates active tribal villages and burial grounds, and relies on a controlling map that is not in the public docket.Read the point +
The BAP and ROD that form the analytical foundation for this rule are available only at an external planning website, not incorporated into the docket. Sixty days is insufficient for the public to locate, read, and comment on hundreds of pages of supporting documents that are not part of the rulemaking record as published. The agency should extend the comment period to at least 90 days and place the full BAP, ROD, IRFA, and map 26-001 directly in the regulations.gov docket.
The notice states that 'since the issuance of the Final Recreational Off-Road Vehicle Management Plan/Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS) in 2000, Superintendents of the National Preserve have managed ORV use in the Original Preserve by designating specific routes and areas.'Read the point +
This means the practical effect in the Original Preserve has been route-specific designation, not preserve-wide openness. The proposed rule, however, does not carry that compendium-based management structure into its text; it simply replaces the map reference, leaving the default rule that all areas shown on the new map are open unless closed by the Superintendent. The agency should explain why it chose a default-open regulatory structure for the Addition rather than codifying a default-closed structure consistent with how the Original Preserve has actually been managed for the past 26 years.
The notice says the rule will have 'no direct effects on other areas' under the Federalism analysis and will 'not result in expenditures by State, local, or Tribal governments' above the UMRA threshold.Read the point +
However, the National Preserve is part of the Big Cypress Swamp, which covers more than 2,400 square miles of southern Florida, and ORV use affects hydrology in a watershed that extends well beyond federal boundaries. The notice makes no attempt to analyze downstream hydrological or water-quality effects on state lands, adjacent private lands, or Tribal lands. The agency should analyze and disclose any hydrological connectivity between the Addition and adjacent non-federal lands, and explain why no state, local, or Tribal government expenditures will result from managing increased ORV-related hydrological impacts.
Say something only you can say. The law requires the agency to consider and respond to substantive comments, and specifics are what make a comment substantive.
PLAN's read: high threat
This rule would open roughly 147,000 acres in the Big Cypress Addition to ORV designation authority, but the controlling map that defines those areas is not available in the public docket.
What’s at risk
If this goes through
Our plain-English read of the official notice ↗. Check it against the agency’s own words below.
By the numbers, from the agency’s own document
- In the Addition, which the rule would open to ORV designation
Purpose and Significance of Big Cypress National Preserve
Open the document ↗“In 1988, Congress expanded the boundary to include within the National Preserve an additional approximately 147,000 acres, an area referred to as the Addition.”
- Total acreage of the National Preserve
Purpose and Significance of Big Cypress National Preserve
Open the document ↗“Protecting over 729,000 acres of this vast swamp, the National Preserve contains a mixture of tropical and temperate plant communities”
- Original Preserve acreage at establishment
Purpose and Significance of Big Cypress National Preserve
Open the document ↗“The original boundary of the preserve surrounded 582,000 acres. This area is referred to as the Original Preserve.”
- Size of Big Cypress Swamp watershed
Purpose and Significance of Big Cypress National Preserve
Open the document ↗“The National Preserve is part of the Big Cypress Swamp, which covers more than 2,400 square miles of southern Florida.”
- Active traditional Tribal villages in the Preserve
Consultation With Indian Tribes (Executive Order 13175 and Department Policy)
Open the document ↗“Currently, there are 15 Miccosukee and Seminole active traditional villages in the National Preserve”
- Years the Addition has been closed to ORV use under existing rules
ORV Management
Open the document ↗“As written, the special regulations give the Superintendent no authority to allow recreational ORV use in the Addition because it was added to the National Preserve in 1988”
Source: the agency’s document ↗
Testing the agency’s case
What the agency argues, and whether its own record backs it
- 1
- Holds up
- 5
- Not backed yet
The National Park Service wants to replace the outdated 1975 map in its Big Cypress off-road vehicle rules with a map of the preserve's current boundary. That change would let the Superintendent designate off-road routes in the Addition, which joined the preserve in 1988. The agency says the current rules leave approximately 147,000 acres outside the framework it uses everywhere else in the preserve.
“This proposed rule would broaden the scope of the existing special regulations so that the long-standing regulatory framework for managing ORV use in the Original Preserve is applied to managing ORV use in the Addition.”
Proposed Rule
Each Ask below goes into your letter when you write it with PLAN on this page, matched to what you tell it about how this land reaches you.
Purpose and needNot backed yetThe current rules rely on an outdated 1975 map. Because the Addition isn't on that map, the Superintendent has no authority to allow off-road use there.
The rules point to a map numbered BC-91-001, dated November 1975, which shows only the Original Preserve. The Addition, approximately 147,000 acres, joined the preserve in 1988. Since the Addition isn't on that map, the general ban on off-road vehicles applies there. The document's own dates and boundary description back the claim that the map is outdated and leaves the Addition out.
The agency’s words, the record +Hide the words
The agency says
“As written, the special regulations give the Superintendent no authority to allow recreational ORV use in the Addition because it was added to the National Preserve in 1988 and therefore is not depicted on the 1975 map.”
ORV Management
Elsewhere in the same document
“Rather, the special regulations refer to a map numbered BC-91-001, dated November 1975.”
ORV Management
“This map depicts the outer boundary of the Original Preserve, which was the extent of the National Preserve in 1975.”
ORV Management
Purpose and needNot backed yetThe rule would increase recreation and access opportunities at the preserve.
Under the current rules, recreational off-road use is banned in the Addition because the Addition isn't on the 1975 map. A map of the current boundary would let the Superintendent designate routes there. The document's own description of the current ban supports the claim that off-road access would grow. How much it grows depends on routes this notice doesn't describe.
The agency’s words, the record +Hide the words
The agency says
“This rule is a ``one-time'' enabling regulation that would allow the Superintendent to expand consumption options for the American public by increasing opportunities for recreation and access at the National Preserve.”
Regulatory Planning and Review (Executive Orders 12866 and 14192)
Elsewhere in the same document
“This means that ORV use is prohibited in the Addition under NPS general regulations that prohibit ORV use except on areas and routes designated in special regulations.”
ORV Management
EffectsNot backed yetOff-road use in the Addition would be limited to designated routes under the record of decision, with no dispersed use.
The agency's strongest support is the record of decision. Its selected alternative allows off-road use only on designated motor vehicle and airboat routes in both the Original Preserve and the Addition, and it doesn't allow dispersed use. Since 2000, Superintendents have used this same framework in the Original Preserve: they designate routes through the Superintendent's Compendium, which closes everything else. Still, the proposed rule text opens every mapped area to motor vehicles unless the Superintendent closes or restricts it. The routes-only limit sits in the Compendium, not in the regulation. The notice also doesn't say whether the Addition designations will be in place when the rule takes effect.
AskWrite the routes-only limit for the Addition into the regulation text, or confirm that the Compendium designations and closures will be in place the day the rule takes effect.
The agency’s words, the record +Hide the words
The agency says
“The Addition is north of Tamiami Trail, meaning that it would become open to ORV use on designated trails consistent with the ROD, which would occur by designating specific routes and areas for ORV use in the Addition through the Superintendent's Compendium.”
Proposed Rule
Elsewhere in the same document
“All other areas within the Original Preserve are open to ORV use under the special regulations, unless closed by the Superintendent.”
ORV Management
Show 2 more claims +Show fewer
EffectsNot backed yetThe rule will have no substantial direct effect on federally recognized Indian Tribes, so Tribal consultation isn't required.
The agency says it reviewed the rule under the executive order and the Department's Tribal consultation policy. The rule itself only replaces map references. Any routes in the Addition would be designated later through the Superintendent's Compendium. The agency found consultation wasn't required, but it still formally consulted the Miccosukee Tribe of Indians of Florida, the Seminole Tribe of Florida and the Seminole Nation of Oklahoma throughout the Backcountry Access Plan. The same section, though, says there are 15 active traditional villages in the preserve, plus active ceremonial grounds and active burial grounds scattered throughout it. Some tribal members also depend on the preserve's resources. The notice doesn't say where these sites are in relation to the Addition or its routes, so it doesn't show the basis for the finding of no substantial direct effect.
AskExplain how the Addition routes avoid active villages, ceremonial grounds and burial grounds, and reconsider whether formal consultation on this rule is required.
The agency’s words, the record +Hide the words
The agency says
“The NPS has evaluated this proposed rule under the criteria in Executive Order 13175 and under the Department's Tribal consultation policy and has determined that Tribal consultation is not required because this rule will have no substantial direct effect on federally recognized Indian Tribes.”
Consultation With Indian Tribes (Executive Order 13175 and Department Policy)
Elsewhere in the same document
“Currently, there are 15 Miccosukee and Seminole active traditional villages in the National Preserve, and more sites that are now considered historic cultural sites, multiple active ceremonial grounds, and active burial grounds scattered throughout the preserve.”
Consultation With Indian Tribes (Executive Order 13175 and Department Policy)
“Some Miccosukee and Seminole Indians who make their homes in the area depend on the resources of the preserve for food, shelter, and spiritual needs.”
Purpose and Significance of Big Cypress National Preserve
EconomicsNot backed yetThe rule won't require state, local or Tribal governments or the private sector to spend money above the unfunded mandates threshold.
The rule only replaces two references to the 1975 map and changes no other provisions. Its effect is to let the Superintendent designate routes. Nothing in the rule text requires governments or businesses to spend money. The fuller economic analysis is in the Regulatory Analysis report, which isn't in this text.
The agency’s words, the record +Hide the words
The agency says
“This regulation will not result in expenditures by State, local, or Tribal governments, in the aggregate, or by the private sector, in excess of the threshold.”
Unfunded Mandates Reform Act
Elsewhere in the same document
“Without changing any other provisions in the special regulations, this rule would replace two references to the 1975 map with references to a map that depicts the current boundary of the National Preserve, which includes the Addition.”
Proposed Rule
Where its own record backs the agency
AuthorityCongress meant to allow off-road vehicles in the preserve under careful regulation, so the Park Service can designate areas for them through a special regulation.Why it holds +
The document quotes the enabling act, which directs rules that limit or control motor vehicles. It also says Park Service rules allow off-road routes to be designated by special regulation in national preserves, and Big Cypress is one. So the cited power covers this action. That power comes with a condition, though: off-road use has to be carefully regulated to protect natural, wildlife and wilderness values.
The agency says
“The legislative history of the enabling act indicates that Congress intended to allow off-road motorized vehicles (ORVs) in the National Preserve, but only if their use is carefully regulated to protect the natural, wildlife, and wilderness values of the preserve.”
Authority To Promulgate Regulations
How this was read
Read from the agency’s own notice ↗, the notice that opens this window; the full analysis comes later, so what it leaves unsupported is what to ask it to show. Every quote is checked word for word against it, a claim marked contradicted stands on a quote from the same document, and a second reading argued the agency’s side of every verdict before it was published. The verdicts are our reading; the quotes are the agency’s. A court can set aside agency action it finds “arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion, or otherwise not in accordance with law” (5 U.S.C. 706(2)(A) ↗), which is why these gaps are worth putting in the record.
In the agency’s own words
The National Park Service proposes to amend special regulations for Big Cypress National Preserve that regulate the use of motorized vehicles off roads. The current regulations refer to a map that identifies areas within the National Preserve where motorized vehicles can be used unless closed by the Superintendent. This map is outdated and does not depict the current boundary of the National Preserve, which was expanded in 1988 by approximately 147,000 acres. This rule would replace references to the outdated map with references to a map showing the current boundary of the National Preserve, with the effect of ex…
Federal Register 2026-20251 ↗Read the docket on regulations.gov ↗
The groups on this fight
6 groups are in this fight, each with its source
Each group is listed for a fact with its source: a case filed over this decision, its own comment on it, or a link to its ground. Give straight to them; nothing routes through us.
Local 2
Headquartered in FL.
In the fight 4
A sourced tie to this fight, from anywhere.
Every group above is on STAND for Public Lands, with its court record, its filings and who backs it.
Who signs it
Kevin J. Lilly
Assistant Secretary for Fish and Wildlife and Parks
Where the notice says so
The ground
Big Cypress National Preserve
In court on this ground
No court case we track is over Big Cypress National Preserve.
Who holds the vote
PLAN’s record doesn’t tie a member of Congress to this fight yet. The scorecard grades the votes and bills that decide public lands; nothing joins a vote or a bill to this decision, so there’s no member to name here without guessing.
See how your members vote ↗Calling your two senators and your representative is the Call door on this page.
On the record for this fight
2 people told us they filed on this fight through PLAN, and 2 have been found on the agency’s own posted comments.
- Judith A.79 seals
- and 1 more steward
Ranked on letters found on the agency’s record, then letters filed. Readers appear as first name and last initial, or as a steward in their state; switch yours off in your record. All boards
Know an open comment period we are missing, or spotted a wrong deadline? .
More fights that need you
Go deeper for free
See how your members of Congress vote on public lands
Every representative, graded on the votes that decide the fate of parks, forests, and refuges.
Open ↗The mapSee the places under active threat
A live map of the parks, monuments, and wild country in the crosshairs right now.
Open ↗A wrong fact, a dead link, a form that wouldn’t take your letter: one tap and it comes to the people who build PLAN, with this fight attached.