All fights
15 days left

Open for comment · closes December 1

Stop the National Park Service from opening 147,000 acres of Big Cypress to off-road vehicles without a public map

National Park Service · Big Cypress National Preserve, FL

What
This rule would open roughly 147,000 acres in the Big Cypress Addition to ORV designation authority, but the controlling map that defines those areas is not available in the public docket.
Where
Big Cypress National Preserve, FL
By when
Comments to National Park Service by December 1, 2026.Date from Federal Register ↗, read October 29, 2026.

What to ask forAll 10 points →

The agency should publish a plain-language summary of the BAP's impact findings for the Addition directly in the rulemaking record, or explain precisely which BAP sections and findings the rule relies on and why those findings are adequate for the regulatory action being taken.

Where these four lines come from
  • WhatOur plain-English read of the Federal Register 2026-20251 ↗. Check it against the agency’s own words under Case.
  • WhereThe places and states the notice names, as PLAN read them.
  • approximately 147,000 acres“In 1988, Congress expanded the boundary to include within the National Preserve an additional approximately 147,000 acres, an area referred to as the Addition.” Purpose and Significance of Big Cypress National Preserve Open the document ↗
  • over 729,000 acres“Protecting over 729,000 acres of this vast swamp, the National Preserve contains a mixture of tropical and temperate plant communities” Purpose and Significance of Big Cypress National Preserve Open the document ↗
  • 582,000 acres“The original boundary of the preserve surrounded 582,000 acres. This area is referred to as the Original Preserve.” Purpose and Significance of Big Cypress National Preserve Open the document ↗
  • By whenDecember 1, 2026, from Federal Register, the notice's DATES field (federalregister.gov API) ↗: “Comments must be received by 11:59 pm EDT on December 1, 2026.”. Read October 29, 2026.
  • Read from PLAN’s record November 16, 2026.
Now make it count15 days left

Two ways to be heard on this, and both count. Comment for the legal record, then call the members who answer to you.

Comment now

What to say

Make these points, in your own words

  • The proposed rule opens approximately 147,000 acres in the Addition to potential ORV use, but the Federal Register notice provides no environmental analysis of its own for that expansion.Read the point +

    The agency says this rule merely implements the ROD and BAP, but the notice contains zero site-specific impact data, no summary of impacts to soils, hydrology, or listed species in the Addition, and no stand-alone NEPA analysis attached to the rulemaking itself. Readers are told only that the BAP EIS exists elsewhere online. Under NEPA, a proposed rule with direct environmental consequences must carry or incorporate by reference a sufficient analytical record in the rulemaking docket. The agency should publish a plain-language summary of the BAP's impact findings for the Addition directly in the rulemaking record, or explain precisely which BAP sections and findings the rule relies on and why those findings are adequate for the regulatory action being taken.

  • The rule characterizes itself as a 'deregulatory action' under Executive Order 14192 that 'expands consumption options' and increases 'recreation and access,' but the same document acknowledges that ORV use has been prohibited in the 147,000-acre Addition since at least 1988 because the 1975 map did not cover it.Read the point +

    Treating the removal of a long-standing prohibition as deregulation that requires no cost-benefit showing contradicts the agency's own account of the legal status quo. The agency should explain why a rule that opens roughly 147,000 additional acres to motorized vehicles qualifies as a purely deregulatory action with no countervailing costs, and it should disclose whether that characterization caused any required economic analyses to be omitted or truncated.

  • The Tribal consultation section concedes that the Miccosukee and Seminole Tribes shared a specific view about the human-land relationship and that the selected alternative was chosen 'in part because it is responsible to the concerns expressed' by the Tribes, yet the notice provides no description of what those concerns were, what routes or areas the Tribes objected to, or how the selected alternative addresses those concerns.Read the point +

    At the same time, the agency determined that formal Tribal consultation was 'not required' for this rulemaking. Given that there are 15 active traditional villages, active ceremonial grounds, and active burial grounds in the Preserve, the agency should either conduct formal Tribal consultation on this proposed rule and publish the results, or explain in detail why the BAP consultation record fully covers the regulatory action now proposed.

  • The notice states that the special regulations refer to a 1975 map and that 'this map is outdated and does not depict the current boundary of the National Preserve,' yet the replacement map (numbered 26-001, dated May 1, 2026) is described only as 'available for public inspection at the office of the Superintendent.'Read the point +

    There is no link, no image, and no description of its contents in the Federal Register notice or the online docket as described. Commenters cannot meaningfully evaluate what areas are being opened or closed without seeing the controlling map. The agency should make map 26-001 directly available in the public docket on regulations.gov before the comment period closes, so that any member of the public can examine it without traveling to Ochopee, Florida.

  • The notice states that ORV use has been managed since 2000 through the Superintendent's Compendium, which designates specific routes and closes all other locations.Read the point +

    It then says this rule will allow the Superintendent to designate routes in the Addition 'consistent with the selected alternative in the ROD, which does not allow for dispersed ORV use.' But the rule text itself does not codify any prohibition on dispersed use in the Addition; it simply opens areas to motorized vehicles subject to the Superintendent's discretion. Nothing in the amended regulatory text prevents a future Superintendent from compendium-opening broad areas rather than discrete routes. The agency should amend the regulatory text to expressly prohibit dispersed ORV use in the Addition and limit authorization to designated routes, matching the stated intent of the ROD.

Say something only you can say. The law requires the agency to consider and respond to substantive comments, and specifics are what make a comment substantive.

Every point is checked against the agency’s own document ↗. 10 findings verified against the text, word for word.