All fights
35 days left
Caribou on foggy tundra

Open for comment · closes December 18

Stop NPS from opening Gates of the Arctic to ORVs without environmental review

Caribou on foggy tundraMore Than Just Parks
What
The agency proposes to open all of Gates of the Arctic National Park and Preserve to ORV use by residents of a 395-person village while relying on a categorical exclusion that bypasses any environmental analysis of impacts on tundra, caribou, or wilderness character.
Where
Gates of the Arctic National Park and Preserve, AK
By when
Comments to National Park Service by December 18, 2026.Date from Federal Register ↗, read October 29, 2026.

What to ask forAll 8 points →

NPS should prepare at minimum an Environmental Assessment, and likely an EIS, to analyze cumulative impacts on tundra, caribou, and wilderness character before finalizing this rule.

Where these four lines come from
  • WhatOur plain-English read of the Federal Register 2026-21300 ↗. Check it against the agency’s own words under Case.
  • WhereThe places and states the notice names, as PLAN read them.
  • 395 residents in 2024“In 2024, Anaktuvuk Pass was home to 395 residents, with Inupiat making up over 84% of the population.” Background Open the document ↗
  • over 84%“In 2024, Anaktuvuk Pass was home to 395 residents, with Inupiat making up over 84% of the population.” Background Open the document ↗
  • at least 30 days“The Superintendent must provide authorized residents with notice of proposed mitigation measures at least 30 days prior to requiring such measures.” § 13.1005 Open the document ↗
  • By whenDecember 18, 2026, from Federal Register, the notice's DATES field (federalregister.gov API) ↗: “Comments must be received by 11:59 pm ET on December 18, 2026.”. Read October 29, 2026.
  • Read from PLAN’s record November 13, 2026.
Now make it count35 days left

Two ways to be heard on this, and both count. Comment for the legal record, then call the members who answer to you.

Comment now

What to say

Make these points, in your own words

  • The agency claims this rule is categorically excluded from NEPA review under DOI NEPA Handbook Appendix section 12.5A(10), which covers modifications to existing regulations, provided the changes do not increase public use to the extent of compromising the nature and character of the area or cause physical damage.Read the point +

    But the rule opens all of Gates of the Arctic to unrestricted ORV use by authorized residents for the first time since 1986, a forty-year prohibition. The document nowhere analyzes whether expanded ORV access across a 8.4-million-acre roadless wilderness park meets the categorical exclusion condition of not increasing public use enough to compromise the area's character. The agency simply asserts the exclusion applies without any analysis of the scale of expanded access. NPS should prepare at minimum an Environmental Assessment, and likely an EIS, to analyze cumulative impacts on tundra, caribou, and wilderness character before finalizing this rule. Section cited: National Environmental Policy Act of 1969.

  • The agency concludes under Executive Order 13175 that this rule would not have substantial direct effects on Alaska Native Tribes, yet the entire justification for the rule rests on protecting the subsistence rights of the Inupiat Nunamiut people of Anaktuvuk Pass, and the document describes the Secretary's directive to complete the regulatory process in consultation with key stakeholders.Read the point +

    The document then states NPS has tentatively concluded the rule lacks substantial direct tribal effects, a conclusion that directly contradicts the rule's own stated purpose of restoring rights central to Nunamiut cultural and physical survival. The agency should explain this contradiction, document the government-to-government consultation that occurred, and release any consultation record before finalizing the rule. Section cited: Consultation With Alaska Native Tribes and Alaska Native Corporations.

  • The proposed rule defines authorized residents exclusively as local rural residents of Anaktuvuk Pass, but the document never analyzes what process, if any, will verify that a given ORV operator qualifies.Read the point +

    With no verification mechanism described, the rule creates a regulatory gap: any enforcement of the general ORV prohibition against non-authorized users must rest on an undefined determination of residency. The document acknowledges the village had 395 residents in 2024, yet gives no guidance on how the Superintendent determines authorized status. The agency should either define a verification or documentation procedure in the rule itself, or provide a supplemental analysis explaining how authorized-resident status will be determined and enforced. Section cited: section 13.1005(a).

  • The document states that DOI is seeking comment specifically on the number of ORVs in use annually in Gates for subsistence purposes and on the expected change as a result of this regulation, admitting it does not know the current baseline or the magnitude of change the rule will produce.Read the point +

    An agency cannot rationally determine that expanded ORV access triggers no extraordinary circumstances under a categorical exclusion when it concedes it lacks basic data on current and future ORV use levels. The agency should commission or require the 1989 NPS study it cites to be updated, establish a current ORV-use baseline, and assess the resource impact of the expected change before finalizing the rule. Section cited: Proposed Rule, Elements of the Rule background.

  • The rule requires that the Superintendent issue mitigation measures only after providing 30 days advance notice, Federal Register publication, consultation, and at least one public hearing.Read the point +

    But the rule also requires that adverse impacts be currently occurring or reasonably foreseeable before mitigation can be imposed. Combined with the prohibition on modeling and climate-based evidence, these procedural requirements could make it practically impossible to impose mitigation before tundra damage or wildlife harassment has already occurred and become irreversible, given the known slow recovery rate of arctic tundra documented in the 1988 Army Corps and NPS studies the document itself cites. The agency should analyze whether the 30-day notice plus consultation sequence is compatible with protecting resources that recover on decadal timescales, and should consider a tiered standard that allows earlier protective action. Section cited: section 13.1005(e)(1) and (e)(2).

Say something only you can say. The law requires the agency to consider and respond to substantive comments, and specifics are what make a comment substantive.

Every point is checked against the agency’s own document ↗. 8 findings verified against the text, word for word.