Open for comment · closes December 4
Demand an EIS before 43,000 acres of Fremont-Winema get herbicide
U.S. Forest Service · Fremont-Winema National Forest, OR
- What
- The Forest Service wants to spray about 43,000 acres of burned Fremont-Winema land with herbicides, including up to 4,930 riparian acres, while analyzing only the plan and doing nothing.
- Where
- Fremont-Winema National Forest, OR
- How much
- Proposed for herbicide treatment: approximately 43,000 acres. Maximum first-entry acres per year: approximately 8,000 acres. Riparian acres within project area: 4,930 acres of RHCAs.
- By when
- Comments to U.S. Forest Service by December 4, 2026.Date from Forest Service CARA comment page ↗, read November 21, 2026.
What to ask forAll 10 points →
The EA says herbicides in riparian areas are safe and limited to aquatic products, yet the hydrology section says the Proposed Action applies herbicides on about 43,000 acres 'including up to 4,930 acres within RHCAs.'
Where these four lines come from
- WhatOur plain-English read of the Forest Service project page ↗. Check it against the agency’s own words under Case.
- WhereThe places and states the project page names, as PLAN read them.
- approximately 43,000 acres“The Forest Service is proposing to treat a total of approximately 43,000 acres of Forest System Lands that have been affected by recent wildfires.” 1.3 Open the document ↗
- approximately 8,000 acres“However, a maximum of approximately 8,000 acres of first entry acres could be treated each year based on funding and capacity.” 1.3 Open the document ↗
- 4,930 acres of RHCAs“The Proposed Action would apply herbicides on approximately 43,000 acres to reduce competing vegetation and accelerate reforestation, including up to 4,930 acres within RHCAs.” 3.7.2 Open the document ↗
- By whenDecember 4, 2026, from Forest Service CARA comment page, the notice text ↗: “requested through 12/4/2026 11:59:59 PM (Pacific Standard Time)”. Read November 21, 2026.
- Read from PLAN’s record November 21, 2026.
Two ways to be heard on this, and both count. Comment for the legal record, then call the members who answer to you.
Comment now10 holes in the agency’s own analysis
Make these points, in your own words
The EA says herbicides in riparian areas are safe and limited to aquatic products, yet the hydrology section says the Proposed Action applies herbicides on about 43,000 acres 'including up to 4,930 acres within RHCAs.'Read the point +
That is every RHCA acre in the project, even though PDC 15 excludes some named RHCAs. Section 3.2.2 also asserts 'no fish or aquatic invertebrate mortality' based on concentrations 'much lower than lethal concentrations' without giving a single concentration, model, or monitoring figure. Ask the agency to publish the modeled concentrations and field data behind the 'minimal effects' conclusion and to state how many RHCA acres will actually be sprayed.
The EA says imazapyr, a product it concedes is 'water-soluble,' is allowed in riparian zones as 'safe,' while its own Table 10 buffer table lists imazapyr in the 'Moderate Risk to Aquatic Organisms' class.Read the point +
Table 14 limits imazapyr near wet soils to 'aquatic formulation only,' but Table 1 recommends a methylated seed oil surfactant for imazapyr and PDC 10 allows only aquatic-approved adjuvants in aquatic settings. The agency should reconcile these statements and explain how a moderate-risk, water-soluble chemical can be called safe for use next to fish-bearing streams.
The agency denies significant effects while admitting the repeated spraying will happen on the same ground.Read the point +
Section 3.3.2 concedes 'Sensitive species may experience decreased population size at individual sites affected by multiple spray entries,' that residual herbicides inhibit germination for one to two years, and that drift can reach plants 7 to 20 feet away. Yet it concludes population-level impacts 'are not expected' with no survey data or quantified drift modeling. Ask the agency to analyze cumulative effects of the 2 to 3 applications per unit on documented sensitive plant occurrences (24 blue-leaved penstemon, 10 green-tinged paintbrush) rather than assert them away.
The EA lists whitebark pine (a federally threatened tree) in the project area and says 'no effect,' but the protective buffers depend on pre-implementation modeling and surveys that have not been done.Read the point +
Marginal, suitable, and optimal habitat total roughly 7,000 acres, yet only 5 known sites (14.74 acres) exist. A 'no effect' finding cannot rest on surveys promised after the decision. Ask the agency to complete the surveys before the decision, or to withdraw the 'no effect' determination and consult with USFWS.
The EA's justification for a single-action, no-comparison analysis rests on a claim that the first-entry area is only 18% of high-severity acres, but its own benefit claims are inconsistent.Read the point +
The cost table assumes herbicide site prep yields 95% seedling survival and releases are 'not needed,' while the purpose and need says 'a typical treatment with advanced competing vegetation would require two or three applications.' The $450 versus $2,200 per acre comparison and the 40,500 versus 4,000 acre outcome are used to justify the project, but no source or study data are shown for the 95% figure. Ask the agency to cite the data behind 95% survival and recompute costs including repeat entries.
The agency uses an emergency authority so that it considers only the Proposed Action and No Action, with no pre-decisional administrative review.Read the point +
No alternative such as spot-only application, reduced acreage, mechanical-plus-targeted herbicide, or phased treatment was developed, even though scoping commenters asked for maximizing spot-spray and limits on acreage. The EA says 'the appropriate method of application will be selected' site by site without defining criteria. Ask the agency to prepare at least one action alternative that limits broadcast spraying, and to explain why the emergency authority justifies skipping a real comparison.
The 'No Action' alternative is framed as doing nothing, but Section 3.10.2 admits it means 'only previously-planned mechanical site preparation or natural regeneration' and mechanical options appear in the cost table at $2,200.Read the point +
The agency never analyzes a middle path (mechanical plus limited spot herbicide) or a smaller treatment area, so the purpose-and-need claim that 'without the full suite of tools' forest cover will be lost is a false binary. Ask the agency to analyze a reduced-acreage or spot-only alternative and disclose its effects side by side.
The wildlife analysis says competing vegetation 'provides minimal wildlife habitat,' yet the document elsewhere says 94 to 96 percent of the project area is early-seral and historically that class should be below 20%, and that scoping commenters raised mule deer shrub habitat, forage, and migration corridors.Read the point +
Section 3.12 never quantifies shrub loss to mule deer (a hunted Management Indicator Species) and relies on PDCs (retain 10 to 40% shrubs) without showing how much acreage that leaves. It also concedes treatment 'may adversely impact' Mardon skipper, two bumble bees, and shiny tightcoil. Ask the agency to quantify deer forage and cover loss by treatment unit and to analyze the sensitive invertebrates directly.
Tribal consultation and First Foods protection are thin.Read the point +
The EA admits that culturally sensitive plants are 'likely existing among the targeted plants,' that spray drift can hit fringe plants, and that wild-harvested food could carry 'toxic residues,' yet it claims consultation is complete because 'no concerns have been raised' by two Tribes who were sent one letter by email. Gathering areas are intentionally undocumented, so the PDCs cannot be shown to avoid them. Ask the agency to conduct meaningful government-to-government consultation with the Klamath Tribes before a decision, and to disclose how undocumented gathering areas will be protected.
The human health section concludes risks are 'minor and temporary' and that exposure 'would be minimized,' but it admits impurities such as hexachlorobenzene and NPE-based surfactants may cause hazards, while PDC 10 bans only POEA and R-11 and the table of products includes Roundup and Hexazinone with 48-hour reentry intervals.Read the point +
Recreation closures run 'less than a month' in 3.9.2 yet PDC 35 says trails close 'no less than 7 days' and 3.9.2 says up to two weeks, so the closure terms conflict. The cumulative exposure for dispersed recreationists, gatherers, and hunters across 43,000 acres of repeated treatment is never quantified. Ask the agency to reconcile the closure durations and publish the hazard quotients for the public.
Say something only you can say. The law requires the agency to consider and respond to substantive comments, and specifics are what make a comment substantive.
Affects public lands
The Forest Service wants to spray about 43,000 acres of burned Fremont-Winema land with herbicides, including up to 4,930 riparian acres, while analyzing only the plan and doing nothing.
What’s at risk
If this goes through
Our plain-English read of the official notice ↗. Check it against the agency’s own words below.
By the numbers, from the agency’s own document
- Acres proposed for herbicide treatment
1.3
Open the document ↗“The Forest Service is proposing to treat a total of approximately 43,000 acres of Forest System Lands that have been affected by recent wildfires.”
- Maximum first-entry acres per year
1.3
Open the document ↗“However, a maximum of approximately 8,000 acres of first entry acres could be treated each year based on funding and capacity.”
- Riparian acres within project area
3.7.2
Open the document ↗“The Proposed Action would apply herbicides on approximately 43,000 acres to reduce competing vegetation and accelerate reforestation, including up to 4,930 acres within RHCAs.”
- Trail miles to be sprayed
1.3
Open the document ↗“Approximately 56 miles (approximately 136 acres) of trail are identified for herbicide treatment to reduce vegetation along trails”
- Seedling survival: claimed vs. recent
Table 13
Open the document ↗“Expected Survival percentage % of Planted Tree Seedlings 20% up to 50% 95%”
- Share of high-severity acres treated
1.3
Open the document ↗“If all 43,000 acres are treated, only 18% of the high severity acres would be treated over the next 8-10 years.”
Source: the agency’s document ↗
The agency’s own analysis
What the notice says, and what it leaves out
Each one is a point a letter can put on the record.
The agency says
“The Proposed Action would apply herbicides on approximately 43,000 acres to reduce competing vegetation and accelerate reforestation, including up to 4,930 acres within RHCAs.”
The EA says herbicides in riparian areas are safe and limited to aquatic products, yet the hydrology section says the Proposed Action applies herbicides on about 43,000 acres 'including up to 4,930 acres within RHCAs.' That is every RHCA acre in the project, even though PDC 15 excludes some named RHCAs.
The agency says
“Some herbicides, such as imazapyr, are water‑soluble, though rapid photodegradation reduces persistence in surface waters.”
The EA says imazapyr, a product it concedes is 'water-soluble,' is allowed in riparian zones as 'safe,' while its own Table 10 buffer table lists imazapyr in the 'Moderate Risk to Aquatic Organisms' class.
The agency says
“Sensitive species may experience decreased population size at individual sites affected by multiple spray entries (some units may require 2–3 treatments).”
The agency denies significant effects while admitting the repeated spraying will happen on the same ground.
The agency says
“Whitebark pine marginal, suitable, and optimal habitat will be surveyed to determine and map the presence of white bark pine.”
The EA lists whitebark pine (a federally threatened tree) in the project area and says 'no effect,' but the protective buffers depend on pre-implementation modeling and surveys that have not been done.
The agency says
“Expected Survival percentage % of Planted Tree Seedlings 20% up to 50% 95%”
The EA's justification for a single-action, no-comparison analysis rests on a claim that the first-entry area is only 18% of high-severity acres, but its own benefit claims are inconsistent.
The agency says
“the Post-fire Competing Vegetation Management Project EA will be developed to consider only a proposed action and no action alternative in detail, and the EA and draft decision will not be subject to pre-decisional administrative review.”
The agency uses an emergency authority so that it considers only the Proposed Action and No Action, with no pre-decisional administrative review.
The agency says
“Under the No Action Alternative, only previously‑planned mechanical site preparation or natural regeneration would occur. Herbicide treatments would not be implemented.”
The 'No Action' alternative is framed as doing nothing, but Section 3.10.2 admits it means 'only previously-planned mechanical site preparation or natural regeneration' and mechanical options appear in the cost table at $2,200.
The agency says
“Competing vegetation does not provide the diversity of habitat structure, tree canopy, and multiple resources needed by most wildlife species.”
The wildlife analysis says competing vegetation 'provides minimal wildlife habitat,' yet the document elsewhere says 94 to 96 percent of the project area is early-seral and historically that class should be below 20%, and that scoping commenters raised mule deer shrub habitat, forage, and migration corridors.
The agency says
“There could be short term direct contamination if herbicides leave toxic residues on wild-harvested food.”
Tribal consultation and First Foods protection are thin.
The agency says
“Short‑term public and worker exposure risks remain low under typical application rates, supported by hazard quotient analyses indicating minimal potential for adverse health effects”
The human health section concludes risks are 'minor and temporary' and that exposure 'would be minimized,' but it admits impurities such as hexachlorobenzene and NPE-based surfactants may cause hazards, while PDC 10 bans only POEA and R-11 and the table of products includes Roundup and Hexazinone with 48-hour reentry intervals.
In the agency’s own words
The Forest Service is proposing to implement herbicide treatments for forest re-establishment and trail maintenance to reduce competing vegetation on approximately 43,000 acres of Forest System Lands that have been impacted by recent wildfires.
Who signs it
The notice names no signer PLAN could read. PLAN names a decision-maker only when the document names one.
The ground
This fight isn’t bound to a map place in PLAN’s record yet. The notice names Fremont-Winema National Forest (OR); none is a unit on the threatened lands map, so there’s no place page to open or watch.
In court on this ground
No court case we track is over Fremont National Forest and Winema National Forest.
Who holds the vote
PLAN’s record doesn’t tie a member of Congress to this fight yet. The scorecard grades the votes and bills that decide public lands; nothing joins a vote or a bill to this decision, so there’s no member to name here without guessing.
See how your members vote ↗Calling your two senators and your representative is the Call door on this page.
Forest ServiceWe track this on the agency’s own system of record, where most on-the-ground decisions live.
Know an open comment period we are missing, or spotted a wrong deadline? .
More fights that need you
Go deeper for free
See how your members of Congress vote on public lands
Every representative, graded on the votes that decide the fate of parks, forests, and refuges.
Open ↗The mapSee the places under active threat
A live map of the parks, monuments, and wild country in the crosshairs right now.
Open ↗A wrong fact, a dead link, a form that wouldn’t take your letter: one tap and it comes to the people who build PLAN, with this fight attached.