All fights
13 days left

Open for comment · closes December 4

Demand an EIS before 43,000 acres of Fremont-Winema get herbicide

U.S. Forest Service · Fremont-Winema National Forest, OR

What
The Forest Service wants to spray about 43,000 acres of burned Fremont-Winema land with herbicides, including up to 4,930 riparian acres, while analyzing only the plan and doing nothing.
Where
Fremont-Winema National Forest, OR
By when
Comments to U.S. Forest Service by December 4, 2026.Date from Forest Service CARA comment page ↗, read November 21, 2026.

What to ask forAll 10 points →

The EA says herbicides in riparian areas are safe and limited to aquatic products, yet the hydrology section says the Proposed Action applies herbicides on about 43,000 acres 'including up to 4,930 acres within RHCAs.'

Where these four lines come from
  • WhatOur plain-English read of the Forest Service project page ↗. Check it against the agency’s own words under Case.
  • WhereThe places and states the project page names, as PLAN read them.
  • approximately 43,000 acres“The Forest Service is proposing to treat a total of approximately 43,000 acres of Forest System Lands that have been affected by recent wildfires.” 1.3 Open the document ↗
  • approximately 8,000 acres“However, a maximum of approximately 8,000 acres of first entry acres could be treated each year based on funding and capacity.” 1.3 Open the document ↗
  • 4,930 acres of RHCAs“The Proposed Action would apply herbicides on approximately 43,000 acres to reduce competing vegetation and accelerate reforestation, including up to 4,930 acres within RHCAs.” 3.7.2 Open the document ↗
  • By whenDecember 4, 2026, from Forest Service CARA comment page, the notice text ↗: “requested through 12/4/2026 11:59:59 PM (Pacific Standard Time)”. Read November 21, 2026.
  • Read from PLAN’s record November 21, 2026.
Now make it count13 days left

Two ways to be heard on this, and both count. Comment for the legal record, then call the members who answer to you.

Comment now

10 holes in the agency’s own analysis

Make these points, in your own words

  • The EA says herbicides in riparian areas are safe and limited to aquatic products, yet the hydrology section says the Proposed Action applies herbicides on about 43,000 acres 'including up to 4,930 acres within RHCAs.'Read the point +

    That is every RHCA acre in the project, even though PDC 15 excludes some named RHCAs. Section 3.2.2 also asserts 'no fish or aquatic invertebrate mortality' based on concentrations 'much lower than lethal concentrations' without giving a single concentration, model, or monitoring figure. Ask the agency to publish the modeled concentrations and field data behind the 'minimal effects' conclusion and to state how many RHCA acres will actually be sprayed.

  • The EA says imazapyr, a product it concedes is 'water-soluble,' is allowed in riparian zones as 'safe,' while its own Table 10 buffer table lists imazapyr in the 'Moderate Risk to Aquatic Organisms' class.Read the point +

    Table 14 limits imazapyr near wet soils to 'aquatic formulation only,' but Table 1 recommends a methylated seed oil surfactant for imazapyr and PDC 10 allows only aquatic-approved adjuvants in aquatic settings. The agency should reconcile these statements and explain how a moderate-risk, water-soluble chemical can be called safe for use next to fish-bearing streams.

  • The agency denies significant effects while admitting the repeated spraying will happen on the same ground.Read the point +

    Section 3.3.2 concedes 'Sensitive species may experience decreased population size at individual sites affected by multiple spray entries,' that residual herbicides inhibit germination for one to two years, and that drift can reach plants 7 to 20 feet away. Yet it concludes population-level impacts 'are not expected' with no survey data or quantified drift modeling. Ask the agency to analyze cumulative effects of the 2 to 3 applications per unit on documented sensitive plant occurrences (24 blue-leaved penstemon, 10 green-tinged paintbrush) rather than assert them away.

  • The EA lists whitebark pine (a federally threatened tree) in the project area and says 'no effect,' but the protective buffers depend on pre-implementation modeling and surveys that have not been done.Read the point +

    Marginal, suitable, and optimal habitat total roughly 7,000 acres, yet only 5 known sites (14.74 acres) exist. A 'no effect' finding cannot rest on surveys promised after the decision. Ask the agency to complete the surveys before the decision, or to withdraw the 'no effect' determination and consult with USFWS.

  • The EA's justification for a single-action, no-comparison analysis rests on a claim that the first-entry area is only 18% of high-severity acres, but its own benefit claims are inconsistent.Read the point +

    The cost table assumes herbicide site prep yields 95% seedling survival and releases are 'not needed,' while the purpose and need says 'a typical treatment with advanced competing vegetation would require two or three applications.' The $450 versus $2,200 per acre comparison and the 40,500 versus 4,000 acre outcome are used to justify the project, but no source or study data are shown for the 95% figure. Ask the agency to cite the data behind 95% survival and recompute costs including repeat entries.

Say something only you can say. The law requires the agency to consider and respond to substantive comments, and specifics are what make a comment substantive.

Every point is checked against the agency’s own document ↗. 10 findings verified against the text, word for word.