All fights
17 days left

Open for comment · closes December 9

Demand real review of NMFS's rewrite of all western Pacific fishing rules

National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration · Pacific Remote Islands Marine National Monument, Pacific Remote Islands Marine National Monument Expansion

What
NMFS rewrote every western Pacific fishing rule, including remote island coral quotas of 1,000 kg a year, after a roughly two-week comment period that drew zero comments.
Where
Pacific Remote Islands Marine National Monument, Pacific Remote Islands Marine National Monument Expansion, Johnston Atoll
By when
Comments to National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration by December 9, 2026.Date from Federal Register ↗, read November 11, 2026.

What to ask forAll 10 points →

NMFS should list every changed prohibition and explain, provision by provision, why each change has no effect on fishing or protected species (SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION).

Where these four lines come from
  • WhatOur plain-English read of the Federal Register 2026-22815 ↗. Check it against the agency’s own words under Case.
  • WhereThe places and states the notice names, as PLAN read them.
  • over 300,000 square nautical miles“This action, which would expand areas open to commercial fishing by over 300,000 square nmi (1,030,000 square km), is necessary” Regulatory Flexibility Act Open the source ↗
  • 50 to 200 nautical miles“exclusive economic zone (EEZ) between 50 to 200 nautical miles (nmi; 93 to 370 kilometers (km)) around Johnston Atoll and Wake and Jarvis Islands” SUMMARY Open the source ↗
  • 163 longline and 13 purse seine vessels“it would likely affect only the 163 permitted and active longline vessels and 13 licensed and active purse seine vessels” Regulatory Flexibility Act Open the source ↗
  • By whenDecember 9, 2026, from Federal Register, the document’s comment close date (federalregister.gov) ↗. Read November 11, 2026.
  • Read from PLAN’s record November 22, 2026.
Now make it count17 days left

Two ways to be heard on this, and both count. Comment for the legal record, then call the members who answer to you.

Comment now

What to say

Make these points, in your own words

  • NMFS says this rewrite changes nothing of substance, yet the same rule deletes four prohibitions, revises the Hawaii bottomfish catch-limit exception, and folds in removals from a separate longline rule.Read the point +

    Labeling it 'no substantive change' sidesteps review of what was actually altered. NMFS should list every changed prohibition and explain, provision by provision, why each change has no effect on fishing or protected species (SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION).

  • After the comment period closed, NMFS added changes from a different rulemaking.Read the point +

    It removed the shallow-set certificate definition and prohibition, removed effort-limitation provisions, and revised the sea turtle interaction limit procedures. The public never saw these in the proposed rule. NMFS should republish these changes for comment or explain why notice and comment wasn't required (Changes From the Proposed Rule).

  • The comment period ran only from November 19 to December 4, 2009, about two weeks, over a holiday, for a rule that rewrites all of 50 CFR part 665.Read the point +

    No one commented. NMFS treats that silence as acceptance instead of asking whether the window was adequate. NMFS should reopen comment for a period long enough to review a rule of this length (Comments and Responses).

  • The finding of no significant impact rests on a PEIS the rule only summarizes.Read the point +

    It doesn't quote the PEIS's impact findings for the remote islands, coral, or protected species. NMFS should put the specific PEIS findings for each geographic area in the record and explain how they support this conclusion (Classification).

  • Around the Pacific Remote Island Areas, no-take protection extends only to the 50-fathom curve at four islands.Read the point +

    Johnston, Palmyra, and Wake get only low-use status, so fishing is allowed there with a permit. NMFS doesn't analyze whether these limits fit the islands' conservation value. NMFS should justify the 50-fathom boundary and analyze extending no-take protection (§ 665.599).

Say something only you can say. The law requires the agency to consider and respond to substantive comments, and specifics are what make a comment substantive.

Every point is checked against the agency’s own document ↗. 10 findings verified against the text, word for word.