Open for comment · closes December 9
Demand real review of NMFS's rewrite of all western Pacific fishing rules
National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration · Pacific Remote Islands Marine National Monument, Pacific Remote Islands Marine National Monument Expansion
- What
- NMFS rewrote every western Pacific fishing rule, including remote island coral quotas of 1,000 kg a year, after a roughly two-week comment period that drew zero comments.
- Where
- Pacific Remote Islands Marine National Monument, Pacific Remote Islands Marine National Monument Expansion, Johnston Atoll
- How much
- Ocean the rule opens to commercial fishing: over 300,000 square nautical miles. The waters reopened around Johnston, Wake and Jarvis: 50 to 200 nautical miles. Active fishing vessels it would likely affect: 163 longline and 13 purse seine vessels.
- By when
- Comments to National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration by December 9, 2026.Date from Federal Register ↗, read November 11, 2026.
What to ask forAll 10 points →
NMFS should list every changed prohibition and explain, provision by provision, why each change has no effect on fishing or protected species (SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION).
Where these four lines come from
- WhatOur plain-English read of the Federal Register 2026-22815 ↗. Check it against the agency’s own words under Case.
- WhereThe places and states the notice names, as PLAN read them.
- over 300,000 square nautical miles“This action, which would expand areas open to commercial fishing by over 300,000 square nmi (1,030,000 square km), is necessary” Regulatory Flexibility Act Open the source ↗
- 50 to 200 nautical miles“exclusive economic zone (EEZ) between 50 to 200 nautical miles (nmi; 93 to 370 kilometers (km)) around Johnston Atoll and Wake and Jarvis Islands” SUMMARY Open the source ↗
- 163 longline and 13 purse seine vessels“it would likely affect only the 163 permitted and active longline vessels and 13 licensed and active purse seine vessels” Regulatory Flexibility Act Open the source ↗
- By whenDecember 9, 2026, from Federal Register, the document’s comment close date (federalregister.gov) ↗. Read November 11, 2026.
- Read from PLAN’s record November 22, 2026.
Two ways to be heard on this, and both count. Comment for the legal record, then call the members who answer to you.
7 taps on Comment, Call and Share here
What to say
Make these points, in your own words
NMFS says this rewrite changes nothing of substance, yet the same rule deletes four prohibitions, revises the Hawaii bottomfish catch-limit exception, and folds in removals from a separate longline rule.Read the point +
Labeling it 'no substantive change' sidesteps review of what was actually altered. NMFS should list every changed prohibition and explain, provision by provision, why each change has no effect on fishing or protected species (SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION).
After the comment period closed, NMFS added changes from a different rulemaking.Read the point +
It removed the shallow-set certificate definition and prohibition, removed effort-limitation provisions, and revised the sea turtle interaction limit procedures. The public never saw these in the proposed rule. NMFS should republish these changes for comment or explain why notice and comment wasn't required (Changes From the Proposed Rule).
The comment period ran only from November 19 to December 4, 2009, about two weeks, over a holiday, for a rule that rewrites all of 50 CFR part 665.Read the point +
No one commented. NMFS treats that silence as acceptance instead of asking whether the window was adequate. NMFS should reopen comment for a period long enough to review a rule of this length (Comments and Responses).
The finding of no significant impact rests on a PEIS the rule only summarizes.Read the point +
It doesn't quote the PEIS's impact findings for the remote islands, coral, or protected species. NMFS should put the specific PEIS findings for each geographic area in the record and explain how they support this conclusion (Classification).
Around the Pacific Remote Island Areas, no-take protection extends only to the 50-fathom curve at four islands.Read the point +
Johnston, Palmyra, and Wake get only low-use status, so fishing is allowed there with a permit. NMFS doesn't analyze whether these limits fit the islands' conservation value. NMFS should justify the 50-fathom boundary and analyze extending no-take protection (§ 665.599).
The rule codifies a 1,000 kg yearly precious coral quota for the remote island exploratory area.Read the point +
That area covers every coral bed around seven islands, and there's no bed-level data behind the number. NMFS should explain the scientific basis for this quota in an area it hasn't surveyed into established or conditional beds (§ 665.667).
The gold coral moratorium ends on a fixed date.Read the point +
The rule gives no review trigger or analysis of what happens to slow-growing gold coral beds once it lapses. NMFS should commit to a status review before expiration (§ 665.669).
In the remote islands, logbooks are due 30 days after a trip, compared with 72 hours for most other permits.Read the point +
This weakens timely monitoring in the most remote and least-enforced waters. NMFS should justify this gap or shorten the deadline (§ 665.14).
NMFS dropped promised fixes to the Northwestern Hawaiian Islands Monument cross-references and set no date for completing them.Read the point +
That leaves monument rules pointing to outdated sections. NMFS should set a deadline for the joint rule (Changes From the Proposed Rule).
The small-business certification relies on a factual basis this rule doesn't reproduce, so readers can't check it.Read the point +
NMFS should include that factual basis in the final rule record (Classification).
Say something only you can say. The law requires the agency to consider and respond to substantive comments, and specifics are what make a comment substantive.
PLAN's read: critical threat
NMFS rewrote every western Pacific fishing rule, including remote island coral quotas of 1,000 kg a year, after a roughly two-week comment period that drew zero comments.
What’s at risk
If this goes through
Our plain-English read of the official notice ↗. Check it against the agency’s own words below.
By the numbers, from the documents on the record
- Ocean the rule opens to commercial fishing
Regulatory Flexibility Act
Open the source ↗“This action, which would expand areas open to commercial fishing by over 300,000 square nmi (1,030,000 square km), is necessary”
- The waters reopened around Johnston, Wake and Jarvis
SUMMARY
Open the source ↗“exclusive economic zone (EEZ) between 50 to 200 nautical miles (nmi; 93 to 370 kilometers (km)) around Johnston Atoll and Wake and Jarvis Islands”
- Active fishing vessels it would likely affect
Regulatory Flexibility Act
Open the source ↗“it would likely affect only the 163 permitted and active longline vessels and 13 licensed and active purse seine vessels”
- Longline effort NMFS expects to move to Johnston Atoll
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION
Open the source ↗“up to a maximum of 6 percent of the total effort of longline fisheries to shift to the Johnston Atoll from areas currently accessible”
Testing the agency’s case
What the agency argues, and whether its own record backs it
- 2
- Hold up
- 4
- Not backed yet
The National Marine Fisheries Service wants to lift the commercial fishing ban in monument waters 50 to 200 nautical miles around Johnston Atoll and Wake and Jarvis Islands, leaving fishing there under existing rules. It says the change is needed to match two presidential proclamations and is seeking comment in light of a court order.
“This action is necessary to conform fishing regulations with Presidential Proclamation 10918 of April 17, 2025--Unleashing American Commercial Fishing in the Pacific, as amended by Presidential Proclamation 11035 of June 11, 2026--Restoring American Commercial Fishing in the Pacific, and in light of a court order.”
SUMMARY
Each Ask below goes into your letter when you write it with PLAN on this page, matched to what you tell it about how this land reaches you.
EffectsNot backed yetExisting fishery rules are enough to manage commercial fishing here and give monument resources proper care and management.
The agency's strongest support is specific: reef and shoreline resources lie within 12 nautical miles, inside the closed 50 nautical mile zone, and pelagic gear stays within 985 feet (300 meters) of the surface, away from seamounts and deep sea corals. It also expects a limited increase in fishing activity and says other federal laws would limit vessel impacts. But for sea turtles, seabirds and other migratory species, it measures effects across each species' whole range and gives no measure inside the monument. The environmental assessment isn't in this text, so this reading covers only this notice.
AskShow, with numbers, how existing rules protect sea turtles, seabirds and other migratory species inside the monument expansion, not just across their whole range.
The agency’s words, the record +Hide the words
The agency says
“Under these existing regulations and restrictions, NMFS believes that commercial fisheries operating in the PRIMNM and PRIMNM Expansion would be appropriately managed and that monument resources would receive proper care and management, consistent with the direction in Proclamation 10918.”
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION
Elsewhere in the same document
“The purpose of the PRIMNM Expansion was to provide an expanded area for the protection of objects of scientific interest identified in the proclamation, including seamounts, deep sea corals, sea turtles, seabirds, and other migratory species.”
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION
“NMFS evaluates the impacts of fishing activity on the population of target stocks and protected species throughout the entirety of their range.”
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION
EffectsNot backed yetBecause catch limits, effort limits and limited-entry permits won't change, the rule will have negligible effects on catch, effort and target fish populations.
The agency's support is that catch and effort limits and limited entry permits won't change, that effort would shift from open areas rather than grow, up to a maximum of 6 percent of total effort, and that combined catch would stay within historical levels. Those limits apply however many vessels fish. Vessel caps do sit above today's fleets, with 40 purse seine licenses and 13 active, and a Hawaii cap of 164 with 149 permitted, but this rule doesn't change those caps. The text gives no catch limit figures, so readers must rely on the regulations it cites.
AskPublish the catch and effort limits, current catch against them, and an estimate of effort if the fleets grow toward their caps of 40 purse seine licenses and 224 longline vessels.
The agency’s words, the record +Hide the words
The agency says
“Because the functional restraints, including catch and effort limits and limited entry permits on the fisheries will not change as a result of this action, NMFS expects negligible impacts on fisheries catch and effort and target fish populations.”
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION
Elsewhere in the same document
“The purse seine fleet is limited to a total of 40 licenses under the SPTA, with 13 active licensed vessels.”
Regulatory Flexibility Act
“The Hawaii longline fishery is capped at 164 vessels with 149 currently permitted.”
Regulatory Flexibility Act
EffectsNot backed yetEffects on cultural resources would be negligible because fishing is far from land-based practices and encounters with practitioners and voyagers are unlikely.
The agency's one data point is that zero cultural practitioners have sought Special Use Permits since the expansion was established, and it cites distance from land-based practices. A permit count speaks only to permitted activity. The text doesn't identify the cultural resources at issue, gives no data on voyagers, and doesn't show how the likelihood of encounters was judged.
AskIdentify the cultural resources and voyaging uses in the expansion, and explain how the agency judged the likelihood of encounters beyond counting Special Use Permits.
The agency’s words, the record and the law +Hide the words
The agency says
“NMFS further expects impacts on cultural resources would be negligible due to the geographic separation from fishing activities and land-based practices and the low likelihood of encounters between cultural practitioners and voyagers and fishing vessels in the PRIMNM Expansion.”
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION
Elsewhere in the same document
“Since the establishment of the PRIMNM Expansion, zero cultural practitioners have sought Special Use Permits for cultural activities.”
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION
The law
“shall take into account the effect of the undertaking on any historic property.” National Historic Preservation Act, 54 U.S.C. 306108 ↗
Show 1 more claim +Show fewer
EconomicsNot backed yetReopening would bring a minor benefit: access to fishing areas closer to home ports, with reduced transit times and lower fuel and operating costs.
The Supplementary Information section says vessels could save on fuel by fishing closer to home ports instead of on the high seas, and the Regulatory Flexibility Act section agrees there could potentially be some savings. But that section says Johnston Atoll and Jarvis Island are far from Honolulu relative to where most longline effort is concentrated, calls transit to Jarvis from the center of purse seine effort significant, and says fuel differences are difficult to estimate. The text doesn't show the savings it credits.
AskReconcile the two sections and estimate fuel and transit changes for each fleet, or drop the claim of fuel savings.
The agency’s words, the record +Hide the words
The agency says
“NMFS expects a likely minor, beneficial impact to fisheries operations and management.”
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION
Elsewhere in the same document
“With regard to longline vessels, there could potentially be some savings in fuel costs associated with this anticipated switched effort; however, both Johnston Atoll and Jarvis Island are far from Honolulu relative to where the majority of longline effort is concentrated.”
Regulatory Flexibility Act
“Transit distances to Jarvis Island from the center of purse seine effort would be significant, but the lack of daily access fees in the PRIMNM Expansion may increase the economic value of reopened areas around Jarvis Island.”
Regulatory Flexibility Act
Where its own record backs the agency
AuthorityThe proclamations themselves lift the monument fishing ban, so the agency has no discretion and must amend its conflicting rules.Why it holds +
The agency quotes Proclamation 11035 saying the proclamation itself removes the ban and that rulemaking is meant to amend inconsistent rules. Proclamation 10918, also quoted, says the Secretary of Commerce shall not prohibit commercial fishing between 50 to 200 nautical miles. Those words reach the waters this rule covers, so the document shows the direction applies to this action.
The agency says
“Proclamation 11035 amended Proclamation 10918 ``to clarify that the proclamation itself removes monument-based prohibitions on commercial fishing and agency rulemaking is intended to amend or repeal inconsistent regulations.''”
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION
Its own record backs it
“This action is necessary to ensure that MSA regulations implementing the PRIA FEP and Pelagics FEP are carried out consistent with Presidential Proclamation 10918, as amended by Proclamation 11035, directing the removal of monument-based prohibitions on commercial fishing in the PRIMNM Expansion.”
Magnuson-Stevens Act
EconomicsThe rule won't have a significant economic impact on a substantial number of small fishing businesses.Why it holds +
The section sets purse seine savings at up to $105,180 per vessel per year, roughly 1 percent of average annual revenue. Its math checks: 6 percent of the 1,753 average sets is about 105 sets, and at $13,000 that comes to $1,367,340, split among 13 vessels. It describes minor benefits, says actual gains would likely be lower, and identifies no significant adverse effect on small businesses.
The agency says
“For the reasons above, NMFS does not expect the proposed action to have a significant economic impact on a substantial number of small entities.”
Regulatory Flexibility Act
Its own record backs it
“Implementing the proposed action could shift the number of purse seine sets in these waters ranging from 0 to 105 sets fleetwide.”
Regulatory Flexibility Act
“These access fees range from $10,000 to $13,000 per day, depending on the EEZ or groups of EEZs that are fished.”
Regulatory Flexibility Act
How this was read
Read from the agency’s own notice ↗, the notice that opens this window; the full analysis comes later, so what it leaves unsupported is what to ask it to show. Every quote is checked word for word against it, a claim marked contradicted stands on a quote from the same document, and a second reading argued the agency’s side of every verdict before it was published. The verdicts are our reading; the quotes are the agency’s. A court can set aside agency action it finds “arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion, or otherwise not in accordance with law” (5 U.S.C. 706(2)(A) ↗), which is why these gaps are worth putting in the record.
In the agency’s own words
NMFS proposes to amend regulations that prohibit commercial fishing in the Pacific Remote Islands Marine National Monument Expansion (PRIMNM Expansion), which comprises waters of the U.S. exclusive economic zone (EEZ) between 50 to 200 nautical miles (nmi; 93 to 370 kilometers (km)) around Johnston Atoll and Wake and Jarvis Islands. This action is necessary to conform fishing regulations with Presidential Proclamation 10918 of April 17, 2025--Unleashing American Commercial Fishing in the Pacific, as amended by Presidential Proclamation 11035 of June 11, 2026--Restoring American Commercial Fishing in the Pacific,…
Federal Register 2026-22815 ↗Read the docket on regulations.gov ↗
The groups on this fight
2 groups are in this fight, each with its source
Each group is listed for a fact with its source: a case filed over this decision, its own comment on it, or a link to its ground. Give straight to them; nothing routes through us.
In the fight 2
A sourced tie to this fight, from anywhere.
Every group above is on STAND for Public Lands, with its court record, its filings and who backs it.
Who signs it
The notice names no signer PLAN could read. PLAN names a decision-maker only when the document names one.
The ground
This fight isn’t bound to a map place in PLAN’s record yet. The notice names Pacific Remote Islands Marine National Monument, Pacific Remote Islands Marine National Monument Expansion, Johnston Atoll, Wake Island, Jarvis Island; none is a unit on the threatened lands map, so there’s no place page to open or watch.
In court on this ground
This fight isn’t bound to a land unit in PLAN’s record yet, so there are no court cases to show for its ground.
Who holds the vote
PLAN’s record doesn’t tie a member of Congress to this fight yet. The scorecard grades the votes and bills that decide public lands; nothing joins a vote or a bill to this decision, so there’s no member to name here without guessing.
See how your members vote ↗Calling your two senators and your representative is the Call door on this page.
On the record for this fight
8 people told us they filed on this fight through PLAN, and 4 have been found on the agency’s own posted comments.
- Amy M.60 seals
- AyreAnna, California53 seals
- Emily, California38 seals
- and 5 more stewards
Ranked on letters found on the agency’s record, then letters filed. Readers appear as first name and last initial, or as a steward in their state; switch yours off in your record. All boards
Know an open comment period we are missing, or spotted a wrong deadline? .
More fights that need you
Go deeper for free
See how your members of Congress vote on public lands
Every representative, graded on the votes that decide the fate of parks, forests, and refuges.
Open ↗The mapSee the places under active threat
A live map of the parks, monuments, and wild country in the crosshairs right now.
Open ↗A wrong fact, a dead link, a form that wouldn’t take your letter: one tap and it comes to the people who build PLAN, with this fight attached.