All fights
14 days left
Bull elk in autumn aspens

Objection window · closes December 2

Demand a full review of Snowmass's 441-acre expansion in lynx habitat

Bull elk in autumn aspensMore Than Just Parks
What
The Forest Service plans about 441.5 acres of disturbance at Snowmass, including 317.5 acres of glading, while calling a 16% loss of suitable lynx habitat in the Action Area insignificant, with only 15 days to comment.
Where
White River National Forest, Aspen-Sopris Ranger District, Elk Camp area, CO
By when
Objections to U.S. Forest Service by December 2, 2026; only people who commented earlier may file one.Date from Forest Service CARA comment page ↗, read November 18, 2026.
Where these four lines come from
  • WhatOur plain-English read of the Forest Service project page ↗. Check it against the agency’s own words under Case.
  • WhereThe places and states the project page names, as PLAN read them.
  • approximately 441.5 acres“In total, there are approximately 441.5 acres that would be impacted by the Proposed Action.” Project Proposal (Proposed Action) Open the document ↗
  • approximately 317.5 acres“ASC proposes to glade approximately 317.5 acres of forest stands at Snowmass” Glading Open the document ↗
  • 345.2 acres, 16% of suitable habitat“The Proposed Action would have a short term adverse effect on approximately 345.2 acres or 16% of the total suitable lynx habitat available in the project area” Effects of Proposed Action Open the document ↗
  • By whenDecember 2, 2026, from Forest Service CARA comment page, the notice text ↗: “requested through 12/2/2026 11:59:59 PM (Mountain Standard Time)”. Read November 18, 2026. 36 CFR 218.6(c) runs an objection clock from the legal notice in the newspaper of record, so take the date from that notice.
  • Read from PLAN’s record November 18, 2026.

This is not a comment period

The comment round on this one is over

What is open now is a pre-decisional objection period. Only individuals and entities that already submitted timely, specific written comments during an earlier public comment opportunity on this project may file an objection (36 CFR 218.5(a)). If you commented, this is your round. If you did not, no filing you send here will be accepted, and the honest thing for us to say is that this door is closed to you rather than to hand you a form.

An organization’s comments count for the organization only. Being a member of a group that commented does not make you eligible; you had to comment in your own name (36 CFR 218.5(c)).

Do not file on our date. Get it from the notice. The objection clock runs from the day the legal notice was published in the forest’s newspaper of record, and that publication date is the exclusive means of calculating it. Objectors may not rely on a date from any other source (36 CFR 218.6(c)). The agency has to post that notice on the web within four days of publishing it (36 CFR 218.7(d)), so it is on the project page.

For what it is worth, the Forest Service comment portal listed December 2, 2026 for this project when we read it. That is the portal’s own field, not the legal notice, and we have not reconciled the two. We would rather show you where it came from than let it stand in for the law.

Now make it count14 days left

The comment round on this one is closed and only people who commented then can object now. What everyone can still do is call the members who answer to them and put the signature on the record.

What to say

Make these points, in your own words

  • The comment window is only 15 days (Nov 18 to Dec 2, 2026), yet the proposal covers about 441.5 acres of disturbance, 317.5 acres of glading, 18 miles of trail work, a new road, a zipline and four resource analyses with technical specialist reports kept in the project record.Read the point +

    That is far too short for the public to review and respond to this much. Ask the agency to extend the comment period substantially and make the specialist reports available with the draft EA.

  • The Lynx section brushes off a 16 percent loss of suitable habitat in the Action Area by calling it insignificant at the 2 percent LAU scale.Read the point +

    The agency itself says the Action Area holds only 12 percent of the LAU's habitat, so the percentage depends entirely on the denominator chosen. The agency's own table also shows 325.1 acres of primary habitat affected. It never explains why the LAU-wide denominator, rather than the area where the loss actually lands, is the right measure. Ask the agency to justify the denominator and analyze the loss at the scale where it occurs.

  • The EA argues the habitat is already so degraded that further loss does not matter, because human use is already inhibiting lynx and the habitat is 'minimally effective.'Read the point +

    That reasoning sets the baseline at the damaged condition and then treats new damage as insignificant. It also conflicts with the agency's own Table 5, which classifies several survey units as lynx forage/travel habitat with moderate to high snowshoe hare density, and with the finding that winter glade maintenance reduces winter cover. Ask the agency to analyze the cumulative effect of this added fragmentation directly instead of discounting it.

  • The EA concludes the ski area provides none of the physical and biological features of lynx critical habitat, based on one March 12 skier-count assessment and a June 22-26 survey, even though the area was designated within the Southern Rockies critical habitat unit on July 16, 2026.Read the point +

    The document admits the project area 'does provide suitable winter conditions' and that some tree islands show hare sign. The EA also gives the habitat area as 2,137 acres while it was identified for its own critical habitat analysis only days before. Ask the agency to wait for USFWS consultation on the Biological Assessment, submitted September 29, 2026, and incorporate the USFWS response before issuing any decision.

  • The watershed analysis leans on small percentage changes from the Proposed Action while admitting that the watersheds are already hugely altered: East Fork Brush Creek peak flow is already 332 percent above baseline, and Brush Creek Tributary 1 is 435 percent above.Read the point +

    The hydrology report sets no numerical significance threshold, and the document concedes the model cannot predict localized erosion or sediment delivery at crossings. Calling these additions minor compounds an already degraded system. Ask the agency to analyze cumulative effects against the baseline and set a defensible significance threshold.

Say something only you can say. The law requires the agency to consider and respond to substantive comments, and specifics are what make a comment substantive.

Every point is checked against the agency’s own document ↗. 10 findings verified against the text, word for word.